Brand like a club

Tuesday 8th July
by Phil Bennett
Category: Journal

Strategy, consistency and belonging. Lessons from the ‘Beautiful Game’.

Those who know me (Phil) will know that this analogy is the extent of my sporting knowledge. However, when looking at Brand Evangelists, the core comparison that came to mind was that of… The Footy!
To give this some context, time after time, we get asked to ‘just put a logo together’. In some instances, sure; this will suffice – maybe you’re looking at an MVP or just looking for something to be used ‘behind the scenes, for now’. But if we’re creating something that needs far and wide reach, builds recognition, and creates a community of evangelists, it’s always just more than a logo.

A brand is a lot like a football club. You need a solid strategy, a distinct style of play, a team that works together, and above all, fans who believe.

The most successful clubs don’t just fill seats; they create lifelong supporters who wear the badge, sing the chants, and shout about their team to anyone who’ll listen. The same is true for the best brands; big or small.

In today’s noisy market, it’s not enough to be seen – brands need to be felt. The most loved brands in the UK connect, as well as sell. They build a culture people want to belong to and in doing so, they turn curious customers into committed evangelists.

So what’s the playbook?

1. Every team needs a game plan

Before a football team steps onto the pitch, there’s a plan. A formation. A set of values. The best brands work the same way. They start with a clear strategy.

Brands like Monzo, Innocent Drinks and LEGO all knew exactly who they were playing for. They understood their audience’s mindset, needs and cultural cues and built everything around that. Monzo rejected the stuffy norms of traditional banking and created a transparent, community-led approach that felt made for a new generation.

This clarity of purpose becomes the spine of the brand. It’s what holds the team together and keeps the fans engaged.

Our take: You don’t win loyalty with guesswork. Strategy is the playbook. It sets the tempo, tone and tactics.

2. Consistency build confidence (and a Badge people want to wear)

The clubs we support are more than just players. They’re colours, chants, home kits, away days. Consistency is what makes it all feel real. For brands, consistency is no different.

John Lewis with its refined, seasonal storytelling and Gymshark with its bold, performance-driven edge are a representation of how strong brands show up recognisably and reliably across every touchpoint. The tone, visuals and messaging are all aligned. It becomes part of your identity.

Think of Innocent Drinks: you could strip away the label and still know it’s them by the cheeky copy to the clean design. That’s not coincidence – it’s considered consistency.

Our take: A consistent brand experience makes people feel at home, and people stay loyal to what feels familiar.

3. Fans want to feel part of something

No one supports a club in silence. Fans want to be involved and feel they have a voice, a place, and a role in the story. Great brands create the same sense of inclusion.

Rapha built much more than a customer base; they built a club. Ride-outs, cafés, kit drops and shared values have made Rapha not just a brand, but a badge of belonging. Their customers are more than buyers – they’re part of the squad.

LEGO does this on a global scale. Adult collector communities, fan-designed sets, and hands-on conventions have all created a brand that people don’t just use, but join.

Our take: Brands that build community, build commitment. People don’t just support a product, they support a purpose.

4. A cohesive matchday experience

When supporting a football club, there are key elements that really make a difference. The walk to the stadium, the scarf around your neck, the atmosphere in the stands, and the people you share that time with. It’s all part of the experience, and the same goes for brands. The journey from first touch to final purchase needs to feel intentional and seamless.

In this case, we turn to NEOM Organics. From product photography to store layout to post-purchase messaging, everything feels calm, considered and connected. It’s not just skincare, it’s a sensorial, emotional brand experience.

Our take: Don’t leave the fan experience to chance. Design it with care and deliver it with consistency.

5. Stand for something bigger than the score

The clubs that win loyalty long-term represent history, values, and culture. They stand for much more than just trophies. That’s what makes the scarf worth wearing.

For brands, purpose is what creates that deeper connection. Who Gives A Crap sold much more than just toilet paper; they sparked conversation about sustainability. Tony’s Chocolonely is another example. They used chocolate to challenge injustice with their customers not just eating the product but talking about the mission behind it.

Our take: Purpose gives people a reason to back your brand beyond the transaction. That’s what creates lifelong supporters.

In summary, think like a club, build like a brand! At its best, a brand doesn’t just attract; it unites. Like a great football club, it brings people together through shared values, experiences and emotional investment. With the right strategy, clear consistency, and a sense of belonging, brands don’t just gain customers – they earn fans.

And fans? They don’t just buy once. They come back. They bring friends. They wear the badge with pride.

RELATED

NEWS

Not Just a Rainbow

A reflection on queer identity, visibility, and why Pride lives in how we work - not just who we are.Dear friends, It’s June and that means Pride...

Read More